As I write this, President Trump has initiated a war against Iran. There is opposition as there should be. Some of it is based on questions about his authority to start a war. There is also support.
When I was in college, at a family gathering I sat with my Great-aunt Margaret. She was in her early 90s at that time. At one point, she looked at me and asked “What do you think of this war, Richard?” She was referring to the Viet Nam War. I said “I think it’s a bad war, Aunt Margaret.” She nodded and said “So do I.” After a pause she added “So many young men…” Later I realized that the Viet Nam War was the fifth war my aunt had lived to see.
So many young men. And now so many young women as well.
When I was in college, I was trying to decide whether or not to file for status as a conscientious objector. I studied the Catholic Church’s position on war. I read Thomas Aquinas and the Just War theory. In a miscalculation, I concluded that I could not claim that status since I had been very violent in my youth, getting into many fights. I later came to see that awareness of this inner violence was the VERY REASON for me to declare myself non-violent. To this day, I know my potential for violence. As much as possible, I decry violence as an option for solving problems.
Like Pete Seeger, though, I also know that, if anyone were to attack my country or my family, as old as I am I would be on the front line.
And so I, as a Catholic man capable of violence, am faced with deciding my position on this current war.
As a psychotherapist, I have spent many hours sitting with combat veterans of all wars since and including World War II. I have born witness to the scars, physical and mental, caused by war. I have listened to many stories of lives changed forever by exposure to death in combat. I have spoken with men and women who lost their faith on the battlefield. I have spoken with men and women carrying a burden of guilt because they survived. I have sat with men and women who have tried to drink or drug or tattoo their pain away. Yes, many of these same veterans tried to face their pain and some did find healing. But they also know that war never really leaves their consciousness.
This for me is the reason to stand in opposition to this current action. War is too high a price to pay for some political or religious advantage. Others may argue about the evils of Islam or Communism or any other Ism. I can only argue in return that there has to be a better way. We must look at war from a human perspective, not from a political one.
Finally I must evaluate war as a Christian. Many Christians and Catholics embrace the Just War theory. Others point to Jesus saying “I come with a sword”. Yet the bottom line of Jesus’ message is that of peace and non-violence, summed up in His words “Love your enemy”, words that are perhaps His greatest challenge. Many so-called Christians may add to that with words like “except” or “unless”. Jesus didn’t add any exceptions.
I can’t change the political environment. I can’t change the minds of those supporting this war. The only contribution I can make is to continue to heal the violence within me, hoping and praying that in some small way that makes a difference. As the hymn says “Let there be peace on earth/And let it begin with me.” Amen to that!
As you reflect on your own views, I leave you with this timeless song that speaks to the realities of war.

