The other day I was conversing with a man who had seen considerable combat and was judging himself for some of the things he did during combat. I asked him whether he had a spiritual perspective and he said “I am a bad Christian.”
These days there are many prominent people who present themselves as good Christians. One views himself as a good enough Christian that he endorsed a specific version of the Bible that also includes the Declaration of Independence as well as the lyrics to a song that celebrates the United States. Another recently stated she received word from God that certain natural events were God’s punishment.. A prominent actor presents himself as a spokesperson against what he sees as negative tendencies in the Catholic Church. A Catholic Bishop takes it upon himself to condemn the Pope. There are others.
At a less political level, I have known many Christians who believe their path is the correct one and that persons on other paths, Christian or otherwise, are at least misguided if not condemned.
Here then is an inventory if you will of what constitutes a bad Christian:
- A bad Christian does not propose that he/she has all the answers. Rather the bad Christian will struggle with questions and doubts and will be comfortable with a statement by psychiatrist Abraham Twerski: “In spirituality, the searching is the finding and the pursuit is the achievement.”
- A bad Christian tries not to be judgmental of others, accepting others even if they make moral choices different than my own. Thus, the bad Christian may not be in agreement but nonetheless does not judge those of a different sexual identity. He/she does not judge those who have had an abortion. And he/she does not assume the worst about the immigrant.
- A bad Christian is open to questioning religious authority. Some good Christians have attacked those who made outcries of clergy abuse and made excuses or minimized the Church’s role. One good Christian I know of minimized the clergy abuse crisis as a “burp” in the history of the Church. Those who challenge the Church on these and other issues can be harshly judged.
- A bad Christian may read Christian writers but also reads thinkers of other perspectives. Thus a bad Christian may read C.S. Lewis but also read Thich Nhat Hahn and Abraham Joshua Heschel
- A bad Christian opposes violence as a solution.
- A bad Christian tends to be suspicious of any politician who claims to be a good Christian.
- A bad Christian may attend Church but not because it is the right thing to do. Rather, he/she attends Church if it somehow helps them on his/her spiritual journey.
- A bad Christian, if he/she prays, does so privately.
- A bad Christian finds the God of his/her understanding in places outside of churches and thus may also be accused of being a “pantheist”.
- A bad Christian believes wealth is to be shared and thus may also be accused of being a socialist.
I have been labelled as a bad Christian on several occasions with terms such as “secularist”, “feminist”, and “enemy of the Church”. So talking about being a bad Christian is not hypothetical for me. In fact, I embrace it.
In case you are wondering, what I said to this man was “The only bad Christians I know of are those who claim to be good Christians and pass judgment on the rest of us.” He found that reassuring.